Growing up in Sheepshead Bay, us as kids/teens swore it was the greatest. As I got older and realized it was Boar's Head meat, I started asking questions. No doubt it is very good and reasonably priced but better than the bodegas only because it's not a bodega and the bread is better. He also has the turnover keeping the stock fresh. One buddy swears it's the spices they use - meh. All said, my chicken cutlet with Mozz was very good. Best to see for yourself, you won't go wrong, you just might not be blown away. He would get the 5 stars if the meat was homemade - at least the roast beef and chicken cutlet.

I rarely get to Jimmy's these days, as I live far away, but when I do, I'm never disappointed. Just had a home-made tuna hero and it was excellent!! Highly recommended!!!

The BEST sandwich shop in brooklyn, we've tried all the hero spots that were recommended but jimmy's takes the cake. Fresh cuts , all the works and prompt service is all you need in a great sandwich shop. Highly highly recommend this spot to anyone catering an event.

BEST SPOT IN BROOKLYN AND IN THE ENTIRE CITY!!! You MUST come here, I've ordered so many times this year with Jimmy''s and every single order was made to perfection!! Extremely FRESH high quality hero's and their macaroni salad and their potato salad is a MUST have. If you are looking for a signature hero that represents New York City this is the perfect spot and you will definitely get your moneys worth. I don't know how they're able to perfect their macaroni salad, but it is truly one of the best I've ever had, and every single opportunity I can splurge, I always pick up some. The staff is amazing and they make every single dish is made out of love. You can literally taste it lol I truly hope this gem will stay open forever because it is the perfect representation of Brooklyn

This sandwich shop is hands down THE best in southern Brooklyn! I just keep coming back for their chicken cutlet hero (chef's kiss). Placed an order for cookies/chips to be added, only to find out that they were unavailable at the moment...got a call back from Frank (nicest guy ever), who offered cannoli & coleslaw instead. Can't praise them enough. Food is always fresh and delicious. Love them. You gotta visit this wonderful shop!!

A classic old school Bklyn hero spot with Only the best from Boars head served Really nice hero's

A nice local spot that you don't see much anymore around Sheepshead Bay. You'll get a nice size hero made with Boars Head. Service is friendly and fast. Check them out on a Jimmy Kimmel sketch

My fiancée treated me to one of the best NY-style delis around! The owner was very gracious, and made us feel welcome from the get go; it was like we were part of the family. When he learned that we were there to order sandwiches to celebrate my birthday (I looooove deli sandwiches), he gave each of us a generous serving of freshly made chicken cutlet to celebrate! Let me just say this: I can see why Jimmy's is famous, and has been around for such a long time! The food was incredible! Everyone that came in, were treated like family; he knew everyone! Now, that's great customer service! The sandwiches were delectable, and chockful of meat and condiments. He made mention that no one has ever finished one of his sandwiches in one sitting, and I was like, "Ooo! A challenge! He doesn't know me that well!" Boy o' boy, I barely finished half of the sandwich when I tapped out! So good, so hearty, all hail Jimmy! We'll be back many times, and will bring family and friends in tow!